top of page

Battle of Brokers - Why a Personal Broker is Worth the Investment in Your Peace of Mind!

Updated: Jun 5, 2023

Cheap vs Valuable

Shopping in general can be overwhelming, especially when you're bombarded with countless online options. It's tempting to go it alone and navigate the sea of offers and prices on your own. But is it always the best choice? In this post, we'll explore the battle of brokers: shopping online for insurance versus having a personal advisor. When it comes to life insurance, there are many options available, each with its own set of pros and cons. Two popular choices are whole life and indexed universal life (IUL) policies. To help you better understand these options, let's compare them to leasing and financing a vehicle.

First up, let's talk about the two main types of life insurance: whole life and indexed universal life. Whole life insurance is like financing a fancy car. You make fixed payments for the life of the policy, just like you would for a car loan, but you can also choose to pay the policy in full and own it outright. This feature is like paying off your car early and owning it free and clear! Plus, whole-life policies come with a little something extra - a cash value that grows over time, like a secret stash of money. You can even take loans against your cash value if you need a little extra cash to splash out on a fancy vacation or other big purchase. And when you finally shuffle off this mortal coil, your beneficiaries will receive the death benefit - just like getting a payout when you trade in your car!

Now, let's look at some pros and cons of whole life policies:

Whole Life Pros:

  1. Premiums remain fixed for the life of the policy

  2. Guaranteed death benefit

  3. Guaranteed cash value accumulation

  4. Dividends may be paid to policyholders

Whole Life Cons:

  1. Higher premiums compared to term life insurance

  2. Limited investment options

  3. May take several years to accumulate significant cash value

On the other hand, indexed universal life insurance is like leasing a car. With a lease, you make monthly payments for a set period of time, usually 2-3 years, and then you have the option to trade in the car for a newer model. Similarly, with indexed universal life insurance, you make payments for a set period of time, and then you have the option to trade in your policy for a newer model with better benefits. However, with a lease, you never actually own the car - and with indexed universal life insurance, you may not end up with as much cash value as you would with a whole-life policy.

Now, let's look at some pros and cons of IULs:

IUL Pros:

  1. Flexible premium payments

  2. Potential for higher cash value accumulation compared to whole-life policies

  3. Ability to earn interest based on market performance

  4. Policyholders can adjust the death benefits and premium payments over time

IUL Cons:

  1. Premiums may increase over time

  2. No guaranteed cash value accumulation

  3. Policyholders may have limited investment options

  4. Can be complex and difficult to understand for some individuals.

Cheap vs Valuable: Brokers

Now that we have a better understanding of the different types of policies, let's explore the pros and cons of working with a personal broker versus an online broker when shopping for life insurance. A personal broker is like having a trusted mechanic who knows your car inside and out. They can recommend the best options for your specific needs, just like a mechanic can recommend the best maintenance plan for your car. Plus, a personal broker can help you with any issues that arise and ensure that your policy stays up-to-date, just like a mechanic can diagnose and fix any problems with your car.

Personal Broker Pros:

  1. Personalized Service: A personal broker can provide you with a more personalized experience. They can take the time to understand your unique needs and provide you with customized recommendations.

  2. Product Knowledge: Personal brokers have extensive knowledge of the products they offer. They can help you navigate the complex world of life insurance and provide you with valuable insights.

  3. Multiple Products: Personal brokers often have access to a wide range of life insurance products from different providers. This means that they can provide you with more options and help you find the policy that best fits your needs.

  4. Relationship Building: A personal broker can provide you with ongoing support and guidance. They can help you make changes to your policy as your needs change and can provide you with valuable advice over the years.

  5. Advocacy: A personal broker can act as your advocate. They can help you navigate the claims process and work with the insurance company on your behalf.

Personal Broker Cons:

  1. Cost: Working with a personal broker can be more expensive than working with an online broker. Personal brokers typically charge a commission for their services, which can add to the cost of your policy.

  2. Time Commitment: Working with a personal broker requires a time commitment. You will need to meet with them to discuss your needs and review policy options, which can be time-consuming.

On the other hand, buying life insurance from an online service is like using a self-service car wash. It may be more convenient and cost-effective, but you may not get the same level of care and attention to detail as you would from a personal broker. Plus, you may not be aware of all the options available to you and may end up with a policy that doesn't meet your specific needs.

Online Broker Pros:

  1. Convenience: Working with an online broker is convenient. You can shop for policies from the comfort of your own home and at any time of the day.

  2. Cost: Online brokers can be cheaper than personal brokers. They typically do not charge a commission for their services, which can help you save money on your policy.

  3. Quick and Easy: Shopping for life insurance online is quick and easy. You can compare policies from different providers and get quotes in a matter of minutes.

Online Broker Cons:

  1. Limited Product Selection: Online brokers typically have a limited selection of products from a single provider. This means that you may not be able to find the policy that best fits your needs.

  2. Lack of Personalization

  3. Limited personal interaction: Online brokers typically operate on a self-service model, which means you'll have limited access to personal advice and support from a broker. This can be especially problematic if you're new to the world of insurance or unsure about the different policy options available to you.

  4. One-size-fits-all approach: Online brokers may not have the ability to offer customized policy solutions tailored to your specific needs and goals. Instead, they may offer a one-size-fits-all approach to insurance, which could mean that you end up with a policy that doesn't meet all of your needs.

  5. Less comprehensive coverage: Because online brokers tend to operate on a digital platform, they may not be able to offer as comprehensive coverage options as a personal broker. This could result in gaps in your insurance coverage that you may not be aware of until it's too late.

  6. Limited policy options: Online brokers may only have a limited number of policy options available for purchase. This means that you may not have access to the full range of policies and benefits that a personal broker can offer you.

So, there you have it - life insurance and cars, two things that may seem unrelated, but actually have a lot in common. And just like with cars, it's important to find the right fit for your needs and budget. Whether you choose whole life or indexed universal life, and whether you work with a personal broker or an online service, make sure you do your research and choose the option that's best for you and your loved ones.

Finally, it's important to remember that insurance is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Every individual's situation and needs are unique, and that's why working with a personal broker can make all the difference. A personal broker will take the time to understand your specific needs, goals, and budget, and create a customized insurance plan that fits your situation perfectly. They can also help you navigate the often-confusing world of insurance, and ensure that you have the coverage you need at a price you can afford.

In conclusion, choosing between a personal broker and an online broker, and between an IUL and a whole life policy, can be a daunting task. It's important to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully and to consider your specific needs and goals. While an online broker may offer convenience and a lower premium, a personal broker can provide invaluable knowledge, experience, and customization. Similarly, while an IUL policy may offer flexibility and potentially higher returns, a whole life policy offers a guaranteed death benefit and a simpler, more straightforward structure. Ultimately, the choice is yours, but by understanding the differences between these options, you can make an informed decision that meets your needs and provides you with the peace of mind that comes with knowing you're covered.


bottom of page